On Tuesday night, the leaders of Victoria’s four major political parties faced off in Melbourne in a televised debate ahead of the November 28 state election.
Hosted by News24 (formerly Sky News) and the Herald Sun, it was between:
- Labor Premier Ben Carroll,
- Liberal Opposition Leader Jess Wilson
- Greens leader Ellen Sandell
- One Nation’s Warren Pickering.
From the 100 undecided voters who attended the debate:

Online poll:

Alexandra Marshall in The Spectator:
This was not as theatrical, in-depth, or instructive as an American presidential debate, nor are its players willing to sink their teeth in beyond a few minor skirmishes. The host, Kieran Gilbert, pushed a little (very briefly and all-too softly), never receiving a direct answer. The closest he got to holding a speaker to account was Greens Leader Ellen Sandell on her refusal to acknowledge rampant antisemitism and acts of violence in pro-Palestine marches during a discussion about introducing permits for protests.
Ms Sandell was the weak link in the debate. She was more polished than Warren Pickering, but like Carroll and Wilson, she was offering pre-rehearsed camouflage for bad policy. Sandell was enticed into accidentally breaking that facade several times, most notably by Pickering who pointed out that ‘free’ promises from the Greens are actually taxpayer-funded costs.
Pickering, in contrast, had no facade to break. His strength is the same as party leader Pauline Hanson – what you see is what you get. Ask him a question and you’ll get an answer, even if it is slightly stuttered under the bright studio lights. …
Premier Ben Carroll and Opposition Leader Jess Wilson are professional, life-long politicians and thoroughly competent when trading blows. They joked and prodded each other, comfortable with the game of politics. It is a skit the voters have seen a thousand times before. Their soundbites, clipped out of the monotony, are polished and convincing. Which is the point. Labor and Liberal are selling the same message: ‘safe pair of hands’. It works a little better for Wilson given Carroll is preaching from the wreck of reality.
This performance had its low points. Particularly, when Wilson was trying to goad Carroll into saying Daniel Andrews’ name, invoking him like a malicious spirit to haunt the election. His refusal to do so was embarrassing and comical (in a depressing way) when Wilson immediately chirped ‘Jeff Kennett’ on demand. This stuff is childish. …
Wilson left shallow wounds on Carroll while talking in circles around left-wing topics and offering clarity on only the least contentious issues, such as tough bail laws.

What’s the point in voting for her?
[Pickering] won when the Liberals refused to answer the question of whether they are against Net Zero.
That just confirmed in many people’s minds that the Liberals are just Labor-lite. Victoria can’t be saved by someone who is frightened to stand up and oppose Net Zero.