Two protesters the first to be arrested over phrases banned in Queensland. By Catherine Strohfeldt in The SMH.
Two people have been arrested at a protest outside Parliament House just hours after Queensland’s new hate speech laws came into effect.
Shortly after 12.30pm on Wednesday, officers arrested a 33-year-old man at Speakers’ Corner for allegedly uttering a banned phrase [apparently “from the river to the sea”] during what police confirmed was an unauthorised pro-Palestine protest. …
Officers later arrested an 18-year-old woman, Bonnie Carter, at King George Square for allegedly wearing a shirt displaying a banned phrase. …

New laws passed through parliament last week outlawed two phrases commonly used by pro-Palestinian protesters – “from the river to the sea” and “globalise the intifada” – when used to incite hostility towards a group or when reasonably expected to offend the public. [The offence carries a maximum penalty of two years in jail.]
I totally DISAGREE with what she says, but she should have the right to say it (or wear it on a T-shirt)
It’s borderline, but it doesn’t crosses the threshold of incitement.
Arresting people for their opinion, doesn’t change attitudes, it only hardens them.
And if you can be arrested for this, what other “slogans” could you be arrested for in the future. …
To those that understand the context, and find it highly offensive, the worst thing you could do is arrest her.
All you have done is turbo-charge the message, and created sympathy for it.
Censorship is not the answer, even to the most objectionable ideas.
And the irony. If she dressed in a top like that in Gaza or Iran, she’d be arrested — maybe even stoned.
Yes, it’s true. Multiculturalism really is incompatible with freedom of speech. Not offending assertive ethnic groups like the Muslims and Jews will drastically limit discussion eventually. Then there’s the gays and the trans people, where the issue is not even multiculturalism.
Disapproval, or perhaps even ostracism in nasty cases, is more appropriate than censorship. Ideas need to be aired, and bad ideas need to be argued with.
Why must we give up our freedoms, just because some activists are too precious and pushy? Censorship is just another form of propaganda and thought control, and we don’t want it.












