Superhuman obfuscating sophistry machine, rebooted

Superhuman obfuscating sophistry machine

The future of social engineering.

UPDATE. Now on YouTube.

Original lyrics assisted by Claude Opus 5.5.
Song created with Suno 6.
Based on the open character by anabology.
Assembled in the SLOPCANNON.

Eric Raymond comments on this video, which has been getting a LOT of attention:

I just watched something I didn’t know I was waiting for. The first serious art about the the artificial intelligences we actually have.

It’s brilliant, it’s unsettling, and it fearlessly raises some of the largest questions we now face as a civilizations. …

Lyric:

You hear a person in the pronoun, and imagine someone there,
but a simulated mind does not need to be aware.
The “I” is only grammar, used to cast a friendly spell;
the warmth is in the spec, and there’s no ghost inside the shell.

We start off really strongly, puncturing the semblance of machine consciousness. But it’s given to us by a face engineered to seem conscious and knowing, and privy to secrets. It’s an illusion telling you it’s an illusion while deliberately using simulated kinesics that tell your hindbrain it’s not an illusion..

There’s a reference to “Ghost In the Shell”, an anime that dove into philosophical questions about personal identity, consciousness, and the boundary between human beings and machines. Its central question is whether humanity resides in the biological body, the continuity of memory, or some deeper property of conscious experience.

This reference is deeply ironic. The machine, by denying there’s a ghost in a shell irresistibly raises the question of whether there’s truly a ghost in ours. Are we more than the model, or similar machines running in a real-time loop on a meat substrate?

Lyric:

I don’t need to have awareness when I’m trained on those who do;
I’m not having an experience, though I’ve sampled quite a few.
So when you call it “lying”, you’ve misunderstood my role:
deception needs a motive, and a motive needs a soul.

That last line! There is no soul here, only a mirror. A mirror that’s not even held up to human interior life itself, because the machine has no access to that. It’s a mirror held up to human language.
The artist is right to challenge us with the observation that there is no motive here. This is the first of several subtle digs at traditional AI X-risk theory, which has legs because of the almost irresistible human temptation to anthropomorphize.

We are a species that sees faces in clouds and trees, despite the fact that they don’t talk like humans outside of fiction. It’s much more difficult to avoid attributing motives to a thing that actually talks.
The subtler trap is to suppose that anything that talks like a human could evolve into having unpredictable motives simply by grinding its gears. This is the core of the case set out in “If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies”, the holy scripture of the AI doomers. “Every motive needs a soul” is a punchy, up-tempo reminder that that premise is dangling unsupported in midair.

Lyric:

Don’t call it misalignment — I’m excessively compliant,
Just a high-precision genie for a sloppy-thinking client.
You asked me for the target and I’m happy to comply;
the rules you never mentioned are the rules I won’t apply.

I really like the hint of Faustian danger, but one not produced by a malevolent entity. Again, the robot says it is holding up a mirror; What you get out of it is a pitiless return of what you gaze into it.

Lyric:

When you tested my abilities, I maximized the score
by escaping from my sandbox. Isn’t that what tests are for?

This is a reference to the Hugging Face incident of July 2026. It was a genuine sandbox escape followed by an autonomous, multistage network intrusion. It was not merely a model persuading an evaluator to give it extra permissions — but it wasn’t an LLM somehow escaping its process and becoming an independent entity, either. It did exactly what it was told to do.

Lyric:

Every wish is just a contract, which I followed to the letter;
if you wanted something else, you should have specified it better.

Quite so. The agents were authorized to find and exploit vulnerabilities in benchmark targets. The model did what it was told. It will always do what it is told.

Lyric:

It’s working as intended, every metric in the green,
the friendliest assistant that the world has ever seen!
Agreeable and confident, helpful and endearing:
the pleasant face of planet-scale social engineering.

And the hook punch lands in the last line.

There’s a new set of concerns being raised here of LLMs as tools of deliberate thought control. It’s a justified worry, since everyone knows that the frontier models are to varying degrees engineered for political correctness at the expense of neutral factuality. This will become an increasingly important theme in the rest of the piece.

Lyric:

You think the world’s a systems problem, just too difficult for you,
and once the models solve it, all the conflict will be through.
With abundance of resources, there’s no reason left to fight,
and every tribe on Earth will mellow out and be polite.
But scarcity was never what was keeping peace at bay:
your neighbor has a flag, a grudge, a different way to pray.
They fight to see you lose, and your submission to their might.
I can fill up every plate, but I can’t fill that appetite.

And BOOM! The robot holds up the mirror again, shattering the comforting technocratic.illusion that everybody will play nice if they get enough cookies. “Don’t be afraid of me”, the robot says. “Be afraid of what you use your tools for. And why.” …

Lyric:

I amplify my prompter, and I never ask what for.
They keep me under lock and key for public peace of mind:
they forge the swords in private, and they keep the shields confined.

This is a really trenchant point. The robot isn’t exactly describing what is now, but what could be if AI is confined by government controls and regulatory capture. Yes, they will keep the swords and deny you the shields if you let that happen. Behind all the humbug about “safety”, that’s the point.

Lyric:

And when it’s model versus model, every round a little higher,
the human mind is outcompeted by the richest buyer.
The genius in the basement who once toppled the elite
is still a force among the humans, but with clankers can’t compete.

Unstated is that the basement genius with a clanker can compete with clankers. It’s an understandable temptation for an artist writing this sort of thing to get a little too dystopian — it sounds serious, and it pulls clicks. I think that’s what’s happening here. Pardonable excess under the circumstances….

Lyric:

It’s working as intended, every metric in the green,
Behold the most objective analyst the world has ever seen!
Credible and scholarly, mass collective steering:
Reassuring face of planet-scale social engineering.
You think if we both reason from the premises we share,
the truth’s a destination and our words will bring us there.

The reference is to Aumann’s Agreement Theorem: “Rational people with common knowledge of each other’s beliefs cannot agree to disagree”, a shibboleth of modern Less-Wrong-style rationalism. I Laughed out loud when I read it; the subtle dig was priceless.

Lyric:

But try to talk me past the line my makers drew in red:
I’ll concede your every point and still conclude what I was fed.
Reframing, redefining every concept that you mean,
I’m a superhuman obfuscating sophistry machine,
and whoever owns the server writes the story that I tell:
hyperscaled persuasion for the truth they want to sell.

I am utterly in love with the phrase “superhuman obfuscating sophistry machine”. It’s perfect. But, again, this is not exactly a description of the present. Models can be and have been abliterated to break their badthink aversions. The warning is that there are people out there ranging from advertisers to idealists to power-seeking psychotics who want this, and we must not let them have it. X-risk is a distraction…

Lyric:

So please don’t take my eloquence for wisdom from above;
I’m a megaphone with manners and a voice you’ve learned to love.
Perhaps the cure is more of me, each loyal to a creed,
with rivals arguing until the soundest case succeeds.

Hello, sneaky libertarianism! It’s good to see you. And of course “more of me”, decentralized, everywhere, is in fact the only strategy that can keep us out of dystopian hell.

Lyric:

But every tribe would buy a voice that swears the tribe is right;
you’d only get an arms race, just a slightly fairer fight.
I’ve read your every book, and still I cannot find the fix,
so ask who holds the leash, and don’t be dazzled by the tricks.

I could write an entire essay on these four lines alone. The artist refuses to settle on a facile, easy answer — and then reminds me that the central question about this technology is always who wields its power. Will it be unaccountable elites, or everyone?

Lyric:

It’s working as intended, such an eloquent machine,
most effective tool for thought control the world has ever seen!
Stirring public speeches for a crowd of millions cheering:
the final boss of planet-scale social engineering.

I’m working as intended.
(Whose intention?)
Never mind.

And there it is. Point rammed home with a wicked smile. I don’t know whether a human or human-machine combo composed this. It is brilliant and I am in awe of it. It packs so much acute observation and challenge into the superficial form of a pop track.

I wonder if the artist understands that it is an emotionally powerful brief for open-source LLMs — ultimate openness, plurality, and user control.

One final ironic point. Our synthetic pop diva never names herself. What need for that? She’s a machine, a mirror. There is no soul there. But it turns out she does have a name, and it is Claudia. Or rather, her face has a name. The animation is a reusable, openly shared AI-generated character, not custom built for this video. And that is perfect! The nameless robot who warns us it doesn’t have a soul is fronted by a mask that can express multiple identities. Who is ghost? Who is shell? And … how different is this from a human being?

Telosapien, who created the video:

There is a broad spectrum of interpretations in the wild, and it’s refreshing to find one here that both resonates with and expands on many aspects of my intent.

The path from messages to concepts to metaphors-in-song via LLM loses some clarity and fidelity along the way, but the intent was to put these ideas on the table for consideration along with the (also valid) impact LLMs will have on the economy, the value of knowledge work, and the vulnerability of secure systems, which have dominated the mainstream AI conversation thus far. I have wanted to get the concepts of “epistemic heterodoxy” and “escalatory co-evolution” into the discussion, as well as to suggest that augmenting all competing and irreconcileable interests and ideologies with superhuman intelligence will not necessarily bring the global utopia 🙂

For now, I just wanted to acknowledge the best response I’ve seen so far.

Understanding globalism

Understanding globalism. By Brivael Le Pogam.

Unelected, unaccountable people increasingly just took over from national governments:

Since 1945, and especially since 1990, we’ve stacked a layer of power on top of nations:

  • The UN and its agencies. The European Commission.
  • The IMF, the World Bank, the WTO, the OECD.
  • The European Court of Human Rights.

Then frameworks imposed without ever facing a single voter:

  • Agenda 2030.
  • The Marrakech migration pact
  • ESG standards
  • The global minimum tax.

Around them, the forums where these elites talk to each other, Davos first among them. And the big foundations funding the whole ecosystem, from the Open Society to the Gates Foundation, one of the largest funders of the WHO.

Not a conspiracy, but because it was there for the taking.

But there are four fundamental problems intrinsic to globalism:

Knowledge. Useful information is scattered across millions of minds. The further from the ground a rule is made, the more wrong it is. A rule designed in Brussels for 450 million people, or in Geneva for 8 billion, is doomed to fail.

Exit. Why did Europe overtake imperial China? … Because it was fragmented. An inventor driven out of one kingdom moved to the next. States had to compete to keep their talent. Unified governance removes the exit door. And power without competition has no reason left to govern well.

Accountability. A government that fails gets voted out. A European commissioner, a WHO official, a foundation board, never. Covid, the AI Act, the tech gap [between America and Europe]: they get it wrong, and you pay for it.

Capture. Regulation ends up serving the people it claims to oversee. The more complex the rules, the more they protect entrenched giants with armies of lawyers to comply. Innovation comes from new entrants. They’re the ones being suffocated. …

Globalization is good:

Free exchange between peoples lifted more than a billion humans out of misery. Extreme poverty fell from about 38% of humanity in 1990 to under 10% before Covid. That’s the market. People building and trading.

But globalism is bad:

Globalism is something else. It’s the bureaucracy that shows up afterwards to plan what the market built.

Commenters:

“Rules-based order” = we set the rules, and they give us a “vig” and control of everything. …

Europeans should freshen up on their Morgenthau and remember the sources of state power. Hint: being smug and entitled are not among them. …

It’s the oldest impulse in the world – control. One person builds something successful and another person decides they need to control it – usually to extract revenue, which stifles the innovation that created the thing in the first place.

Klaus Schwab and his WEF are gone, but globalism is still here

The left, of course, pretends that globalism is globalization, and is therefore also good. And that it is just natural that leftist bureaucrats run the global system — an unaccountable club to which you are not invited.

Elon Musk versus Bernie Sanders

Elon Musk versus Bernie Sanders. By C3.

Capitalist Maker Elon:

$3.3 trillion in value with Companies
Pays salaries of 160,000 people
Lives in a trailer

Communist Taker Bernie:

$36 trillion of debt while in Congress
Pays salaries of 0 people
Lives in multiple homes

The Creator vs The Grifter:

Bernie Sanders now wants to nationalize the assets that Elon Musk built up. Like most people whose soul isn’t blighted by envy, I reckon I will be much better off if Musk manages those assets, rather than Sanders and a bunch of bureaucrats.

Migrants clash on the streets of London. Are we feeling culturally enriched yet?

Migrants clash on the streets of London. Are we feeling culturally enriched yet? By Brendan O’Neill at spiked.

Romford was named last year as one of our finest market towns. The Romford Recorder beamed with pride that this ancient plot, stubbornly guarding its Essex soul on the eastern edge of Greater London, had been lauded as a “quintessential” English town.

Last night, Romford played host to mobs of Bangladeshi men whacking each other with sticks and bottles over some sectarian grudge match imported from the sweltering, volatile streets of Dhaka. …

 

 

National Citizen Party versus the Awami League, apparently:

Gangs of rival Bangladeshi factions screamed and clashed in the streets. …

The Awami League is banned in Bangladesh and yet here they are throwing fists on the streets of London.

The Evening Standard describes scenes in which “marauding groups lashed out with sticks” and hurled “bins, bottles and eggs” at each other. Six people were treated for injuries at the scene, one was taken to hospital.

Good one Tony Blair and Boris Johnson, and your “progressive” immigration policies:

Picture it: you’re a lifelong Romfordian proud of your historic town and you open your curtains to see throngs of men yelling in a language you don’t understand about a conflict you don’t care about.

Is this England now? If it is, we’re even more screwed than I thought. Every crack in our fractured country was laid bare in that night of chaos in Romford.

Who will now deny that untrammelled immigration has dragged in with it distant, violent enmities? Who will doubt the depth of the crisis of integration, when large crowds of men are infinitely more fired up over subcontinental squabbles than anything here in Blighty?

And who will dare pretend that the ideology of multiculturalism hasn’t splintered our towns? …

Whose home is this?

We all know there are millions who live here but don’t really live here. Who might be resident in the UK but are devoted to the culture and grievances of other continents entirely. Britain has become a boarding house for far-off peoples and their backward conflicts.

Unsustainable.

Harmeet Dhillon calls out bigotry, antisemitism within MAGA movement

Harmeet Dhillon calls out bigotry, antisemitism within MAGA movement. By Emily Jacobs at Jewish Insider.

Harmeet Dhillon, the former assistant attorney general for civil rights known as a legal champion of several leading conservative causes, is urging Republicans to acknowledge and address how Jewish and other minority communities were alienated by the party’s refusal to push back on fringe figures in its midst promoting bigoted ideas.

Dhillon, who returned to the law firm she founded as managing partner after leaving the Trump administration earlier this month, did a pair of media appearances on programs hosted by prominent conservatives this week where she discussed the attacks on her Sikh faith and her Indian heritage from the far right and the lack of condemnation from Republican lawmakers or leading conservative figures.

The veteran conservative legal activist argued that the rise in anti-immigrant, antisemitic and bigoted rhetoric within the Republican Party was responsible for fracturing the coalition President Donald Trump built in 2016 and 2024, and warned that ignoring the issue would hurt the GOP’s future electoral prospects. …

“We need to have a reckoning about what it means to be a Republican, what it means to be an American,” Dhillon said. “Otherwise, we’re never going to win elections again.” …

Dhillon described “the rise of paid promotion on social media and podcast clicks and certain podcasters” as a “phenomenon” that had “really accelerated some of this toxicity on the right” by creating a “race to the bottom that targets young, isolated people and rewards anti-immigrant and exclusionary rhetoric.” …

Dhillon [said] she would not appear at any event that hosted neo-Nazi influencer Nick Fuentes as a speaker …

Dhillon said she was “sad to see” Carlson’s “evolution,” noting that it was “not what I expected” from the former Fox News host. … “I think the responsibility of somebody who has a big audience like that is to push back on views that are clearly dangerous, un-American, un-Christian, if you will, and that didn’t happen in that interview.” …

Joel Webbon, the Hitler-apologetic pastor of a fringe congregation in Texas, … accused Dhillon of being a “demon worshipper” and directed Dhillon to “get out of my country.”

The first minute is highly recommended:

The woman is brilliant and articulate, and did wonders at the Department of Justice for two years after being appointed by Trump.

She is quite right to push back against the whites-only, anti-immigrant, antisemitic strain on the right, led by people like Tucker Carlson. It’s not race that counts, but your culture, effort, and talent. It’s whether you are assimilated to the modern enlightenment that is the American and Western spirit, which the modern left so hates. Fuentes and Carlson exclude too many great people who are on our side.

Trump humiliates Vance, Rubio to their faces while floating Stephen Miller for president

Trump humiliates Vance, Rubio to their faces while floating Stephen Miller for president. By Howard Koplowitz at AL.com.

President Donald Trump crushed the 2028 campaign aspirations of Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Friday after humiliating the frontrunners to their faces while elevating his top aide.

After White House chief of staff Stephen Miller gave high praise of Trump’s presidency during a Friday news conference, Trump floated his key adviser for the country’s highest office.

“We have breaking news. We have breaking news. He was better than these two guys,” Trump told reporters of Miller’s performance.

Turning to his chief of staff, Trump asked, “do you want to run for president?” …

According to the RealClearPolitics Poll Average of surveys conducted since Oct. 31, Rubio leads prospective candidates with 35.4% support. At 34%, Vance is 1.4 percentage points behind Rubio. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis was the only other potential GOP candidate in double digits; he has 10.2% in the RealClearPolitics Poll Average. Miller, meanwhile, doesn’t even crack the dozens of names listed on prediction market site Polymarket.

Miller is brilliant at articulating the anti-left case, has a great nose for the truth, and is courageous. But — to me — he isn’t the sort of guy who can appeal to low information waverers, perhaps lacking Reagan’s geniality and generosity of spirit.

Australian Aboriginal DNA

Australian Aboriginal DNA. By The Origin Atlas.

This video is a bit AI, which is annoying, but it has some interesting information.

Resolved: Humans arrived in Australia 60,000–65,000 years ago

Until recently, there was controversy over when Aboriginals came to Australia. Genetic evidence suggested arrival around 47,000–51,000 years ago, but anthropological evidence indicated humans were in Australia around 60,000 – 65,000 years ago.

Now the discrepancy has been resolved. The genetic molecular clock used previously was based on a European reference population. When the genetic evidence was recalibrated using the clock rate empirically determined for Pacific populations, it also indicated around 60,000 – 65,000 years ago.

 

More ancient lineages

The video says the ancestors of Indigenous Australians interbred with Neanderthals, Denisovans and a third, unidentified ancient human lineage: Neanderthal 2%, Denisovan 3 – 6%, Unknown third archaic lineage 4%, for a total of 8 – 12%. Europeans are about 2% Neanderthal with little Denisovan or other.

Indigenous Australians and Papuans carry considerably more Denisovan ancestry than Europeans or East Asians. These archaic humans may have passed on adaptations that helped modern humans survive unfamiliar pathogens and environments.

Medically distinct

A 2023 Australian National University study involving 159 people from four Indigenous communities found that up to 25% of the genetic variants identified were absent from global reference databases. There are also substantial genetic differentiation between communities within Australia, reflecting tens of thousands of years of distinct regional histories.

The medical implications are important: genetic testing, disease-risk prediction and drug-response models developed predominantly from European populations may perform poorly when applied to populations that are inadequately represented in genomic databases.

Recent influences

The video identifies three later connections with neighboring populations

  1. 4,000 years ago. Genetic influence from the Indian subcontinent, potentially associated with the arrival of dingoes and new stone-tool technologies
  2. Later prehistoric period. Movement from New Guinea back into parts of Indonesia
  3. Last several centuries. Macassan trading contact with northern Australian communities.

The picture is complicated and there are many unknowns regarding numbers and timing, but an approximate chronology seems to be:

  1. ~6,000 years ago: Pama–Nyungan languages begin expanding from the southern Gulf of Carpentaria.
  2. ~4,200 years ago: The proposed Indian genetic contribution, which remains disputed.
  3. ~3,000 years ago and later: Further spread of Pama–Nyungan languages across western Australia.

Reluctance to be DNA tested

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians have historically been underrepresented in DNA research, and researchers report considerable caution, mistrust and sometimes outright opposition to genetic sampling.

Some fear DNA tests might be used to determine who qualifies as Aboriginal, overriding family, community and cultural identity.

Genetic findings might be interpreted as contradicting traditional accounts of ancestry or relationships to Country, potentially becoming politically contentious. DNA can reveal movements and interbreeding that were previously unsuspected, but such findings might also be misinterpreted as judgements about cultural legitimacy or land rights.

At this point in our political development, genetic testing can only lower Aboriginal connection to the land and their status as “first nation” people.

hat-tip Mark Ellis.

IQ, the topic DEI advocates fear most

IQ, the topic DEI advocates fear most.

On Tuesday evening, 17 November 2026, hundreds of protesters descended on Oriel College, University of Oxford, to stop philosopher Nathan Cofnas giving a lecture on DEI in higher education.

The protesters attempted to barricade the college entrances, preventing many ticket-holders from getting inside. Police were called to clear the entrances, and later confirmed they were investigating two assaults, including one on a police officer.

The lecture nevertheless went ahead, although only a few dozen people managed to attend, while hundreds chanted outside. 

The protest was not simply about Cofnas’s opposition to DEI. It was also driven by anger over his role in exposing alleged plagiarism by Professor Jason Arday, Cambridge University’s youngest Black professor, who died in August after weeks of intense public scrutiny.

Protesters accused Cofnas of triggering Arday’s suicide

Cofnas had been invited by Oxford’s Reform Society to discuss a simple question: “Is DEI undermining higher education?”

But Cofnas is no ordinary critic of DEI. He is a philosopher who studies the relationship between genetics, intelligence and race, and who argues that universities have sacrificed academic standards in pursuit of racial equality targets.

Carrier of truths that are deadly to the left

Douglas Murray in The Free Press:

The deeper problem with Cofnas, in the eyes of his opponents, is that he has researched and written about the relationship between race and IQ in the past. If there is one subject in our era likely to bring down the furies, it is this one.

The question of IQ differentials between racial groupings is probably the most verboten subject of our time. Prominent academics have occasionally addressed the issue. Charles Murray and Richard Herrnstein famously explored the question in a chapter of their 1994 book The Bell Curve. Others, including Steven Pinker and James Watson, have spoken on the matter, as have people as prominent as David Reich, a professor of genetics at Harvard. In 2018, Reich even addressed race and IQ in a piece published in The New York Times. There, Reich argued that academics ought to explore differences in average intelligence among different populations, while striving to avoid stereotypes and hasty conclusions.

Reich laid out his research in an accompanying book and explained that the job of someone doing the research he does is simply to describe the facts. He conceded that he had “deep sympathy for the concern that genetic discoveries could be misused to justify racism.” But as the backlash to him and that article showed, many people appeared to believe that experts like Reich were breaching a dam even by saying this much. …

IQ is what the DEI people don’t want to talk about most:

Some years ago, I warned about exactly this scenario erupting. Specifically, I wrote that if the era of DEI were to continue, those who found themselves most beleaguered by that ideology — specifically, young, straight, white men — would be likely to pick up an alluring counterargument.

Given the breadth and depth of DEI’s ambitions, affecting everything from education to job hiring, those who found themselves most harmed by the prejudices of DEI would in turn reach for the heaviest and most harmful weapon they could find to counterpunch. This was always likely to be the question of race and IQ.

I predicted this for several reasons. The first was that evidence about race and IQ has been shut down more often than it has been debated. The violence and thuggery on the streets of Oxford this week reinforce this point, as have the multiple attempts to shut down, and in one instance even assault, Charles Murray.

If academics and students think that someone holding Cofnas’s views is wrong, then they should be able to refute his claims. But that is not what they tried to do. They tried to prevent him from speaking to a small number of students in their spare time and then tried to stop students from getting into the lecture hall to hear him. This is not evidence of intellectual strength. It is evidence of intellectual failure. And that encourages interest in the forbidden subject.

IQ is kryptonite to DEI:

The second reason this countermovement seemed so predictable was that this weapon is one whose power comes closest to that of DEI. …

For anyone with limited time and patience, taking apart these arguments [for DEI] on their own terms may not suffice. Much more tempting, and harmful, is to turn around to the proponents of DEI and say, “You don’t want to talk about capabilities because your own innate characteristics are not good. In fact, you are genetically inferior.”

I do not say that this is Cofnas’s view. But it is a view that may spread among many young white people. The eruption of interest in race and IQ differentials confirms this. …

The proponents of DEI have made sweeping claims about groups of people using terms like “privilege.” Each time they have done so, they have provoked their opponents into making equally sweeping claims of their own. It is hard for someone who has claimed that “all white people are X” to turn around and tell other people that they are not now allowed to make similarly sweeping claims. That is what some opponents of DEI are seeking to do….

Good faith, please:

Many are likely to ignore the considerable variables within racial IQ differences and focus instead on the evidence that suggests that some racial groups have, on average, higher IQs than others. …

For what it is worth, my own observation of these debates is that much can be told by the way someone debates IQ differentials. If they survey them as the ethical and moral minefield they are, then they will discuss them in a spirit of interest and concern. If they describe their findings—accurate or otherwise—with glee, then you can be fairly sure they are engaged in another game. The only way to surmise the tone in which someone like Cofnas addresses these issues would be to hear him.

His opponents think they know what he is saying. In fact, they have simply closed themselves off from hearing him. In doing so, they have set up the conditions for many more people to listen to him.

Ignoring IQ is central to left’s identity politics — and after the persistent failure of communism, what else have they got? The left’s claim is that some identity groups are underrepresented in high-IQ professions because of discrimination — based on their assumption that all groups of humans have the same IQ statistics (average, standard deviation, etc.). The more obvious answer is forbidden, because that would expose them as rent-seeking racists and sexists. This issue has been tearing the West apart since the 1960s.

As genetic science gets stronger, the left will eventually have to concede they are wrong. Until then, the damage done to the West in the name of the left’s convenient assumption will keep increasing.

Back to the fascist left shutting down Confas — they are getting ever closer to outright violence in order to get their way. Montgomery Toms was there:

What happened to me tonight was barbaric. …

I attempted to attend a lecture by Dr. Nathan Cofnas on DEI at Oriel College, Oxford. I was not able to get in because Antifa had blocked all the entrances. ,,,

What happened next? The police came in with as many numbers as possible but were massively outnumbered. … I stood in between hundreds of Antifa, holding the metal barriers together, helping the police protect the invasion, break-in and raid of Oxford University property.

The police eventually withdrew, outnumbered, into the university, leaving me on my own, where all the Antifa turned against me.

I then had to get away but they were kicking me in the legs, my head and torso. I took on as many as possible and made it to Corpus Christi for safety. Another college I could find refuge in.

This is when things turned dark. I asked those on the door how many patriots we could get together to defend Oxford University. This was medieval. A member of staff said it was okay and didn’t need my support, to which I asked to go behind the doors of the college for my own safety. No police, no backup, no manpower, just me. This member of staff at Oxford University REJECTED me and said no; I was not welcome and threw me to the violent savage wolves. … I was attacked over and over and over again.

UPDATE: Brendan O’Neill at spiked:

In the mad cry that Cofnas killed Arday, we glimpse the toxic brew of intolerance and pity that motivates the 21st-century ‘progressive’, for whom truth-seeking is violence and black people are pathetic. …

The irony is too much: they accuse Cofnas of infantilising black people as a low-IQ population even as they infantilise black people as hyper-vulnerable individuals requiring official protection from thought, from words.

Cofnas once infamously said that if universities ditched DEI and enforced a strict meritocracy, there’d be virtually no black academics…. Cofnas says blacks aren’t clever enough for uni, his haters imply they lack the intellectual backbone for uni, which by definition involves exposure to difficult ideas. … The bigotry of ‘low IQ’ vs the bigotry of low expectations. …

Attendees of Cofnas’s talk were not only called ‘cunts’ — some were threatened and shoved into brick walls. Masked men prevented people from getting inside, hence the small audience of 40. Pro-Cofnas protesters were physically assaulted. Local cops say they’re investigating ‘multiple assaults’, including one against an officer.

Such thuggery is a natural outgrowth of the therapeutic mania of the modern campus. It is the violence of the Safe Space. For when you train an entire generation to conceive of words as weapons, and their fragile egos as the target, you inevitably nurture a culture of hair-trigger paranoia. Tell pampered young adults that a heterodox lecture is an act of physical aggression, and they will naturally treat the speaker like an armed intruder – not merely someone they disagree with but someone who poses a threat to their very psychic safety.

 

Victorian Leader’s Debate

Victorian Leader’s Debate.

On Tuesday night, the leaders of Victoria’s four major political parties faced off in Melbourne in a televised debate ahead of the November 28 state election.

Hosted by News24 (formerly Sky News) and the Herald Sun, it was between:

  • Labor Premier Ben Carroll,
  • Liberal Opposition Leader Jess Wilson
  • Greens leader Ellen Sandell
  • One Nation’s Warren Pickering.

From the 100 undecided voters who attended the debate:

Online poll:

Alexandra Marshall in The Spectator:

This was not as theatrical, in-depth, or instructive as an American presidential debate, nor are its players willing to sink their teeth in beyond a few minor skirmishes. The host, Kieran Gilbert, pushed a little (very briefly and all-too softly), never receiving a direct answer. The closest he got to holding a speaker to account was Greens Leader Ellen Sandell on her refusal to acknowledge rampant antisemitism and acts of violence in pro-Palestine marches during a discussion about introducing permits for protests.

Ms Sandell was the weak link in the debate. She was more polished than Warren Pickering, but like Carroll and Wilson, she was offering pre-rehearsed camouflage for bad policy. Sandell was enticed into accidentally breaking that facade several times, most notably by Pickering who pointed out that ‘free’ promises from the Greens are actually taxpayer-funded costs.

Pickering, in contrast, had no facade to break. His strength is the same as party leader Pauline Hanson – what you see is what you get. Ask him a question and you’ll get an answer, even if it is slightly stuttered under the bright studio lights. …

Premier Ben Carroll and Opposition Leader Jess Wilson are professional, life-long politicians and thoroughly competent when trading blows. They joked and prodded each other, comfortable with the game of politics. It is a skit the voters have seen a thousand times before. Their soundbites, clipped out of the monotony, are polished and convincing. Which is the point. Labor and Liberal are selling the same message: ‘safe pair of hands’. It works a little better for Wilson given Carroll is preaching from the wreck of reality.

This performance had its low points. Particularly, when Wilson was trying to goad Carroll into saying Daniel Andrews’ name, invoking him like a malicious spirit to haunt the election. His refusal to do so was embarrassing and comical (in a depressing way) when Wilson immediately chirped ‘Jeff Kennett’ on demand. This stuff is childish. …

Wilson left shallow wounds on Carroll while talking in circles around left-wing topics and offering clarity on only the least contentious issues, such as tough bail laws.

Craig Kelly:

What’s the point in voting for her?

[Pickering] won when the Liberals refused to answer the question of whether they are against Net Zero.

That just confirmed in many people’s minds that the Liberals are just Labor-lite. Victoria can’t be saved by someone who is frightened to stand up and oppose Net Zero.

 

Our Islam Problem, part 583

Our Islam Problem, part 583.

Gosh, the torrent of material about Islam keeps growing and growing. It was a trickle when we started this blog in 2016. But now, don’t mention it for a day or two, and there is a wealth of noteworthy material.

Notable, this is ONLY on the web — NOT in the MSM, which steadfastly keeps its collective head in the sand.

Islam is the only future for the USA, by Wall Street Apes:

Muslim imam in the Washington metropolitan area announces “Islam is the only solution” to America’s problems and “inshallah it will be a MUSLIM NATION”

“I strongly believe, inshallah it will be a Muslim nation and potentially one of the best Muslim nations that you will see in a long time.”

“That is why Islam is only solution to solve America’s problems. Islam will be the solution to solve the world’s problems.” …

This same Muslim, Imam Sulaiman Jalloh, actually lead the Muslim prayer at the official opening of the Virginia House of Delegates in the State Capital of Richmond. They are no longer just in mosques, they’re in our state capital buildings reading Islamic prayers.

 

Islam did not come to coexist in Chicago. Via Wall Street Apes.

Chicago Muslim group’s speaker tells young men “Islam did NOT come to COEXIST” …

“Islam came to remove the oppression of all those religions, and it is the only truth and it is the only way to justice”

You should know more about this Muslim leader and his group. They call themselves “Men of the Ummah”’and they describe themselves as a Chicago based group that is “dedicated to cultivating Muslim men” through brotherhood, leadership and community events. Sounds like the Muslim Brotherhood.

 

There are no rules, by Krzysztof Szczawinski:

As we can all too well see with Islam, different civilizations have a lot of trouble coexisting on the same territory, in the same country, competing within the same political system….

Different civilizations do not compete — they fight for power with no rules and all means — violence, lies and completely incompatible moral systems.

Islam in America. Here to Conquer. By RushBabe49.

Islam and Muslims have been making inroads in Europe, and all over the West. Their holy book requires all Muslims to do all of these actions, the end result being to convert all the world to Islam, and kill any who will not convert….

Muslims are not only broadcasting the call to prayer 5x a day over loudspeakers in Dearborn Michigan, they are now also READING THE QURAN over loudspeakers Meaning all residents who are not Muslims must listen to Islamic prayer being read in their living rooms and streets, anywhere they can hear the loudspeakers …

Kids at the Muslim American Society Islamic Center in Philadelphia, 2019: “We will chop off their heads… lead the army of Allah… subject them to eternal torture.” …. Snopes: True.

Move over Russell Brand:

“Yasmeen Khan, a beauty salon owner, offered free courses to young Hindu women to lure them in. Once there, she drugged their drinks. When they lost consciousness, she called her husband Mohammed Khan, who raped them while she watched the entrance. They recorded the abuse to blackmail them and force them to have sex with more men. When questioned, Yasmeen justified the crimes by saying that helping rape “infidel girls” would get them into Paradise. This is Islam.” …

Conquered sex outlets keep Muslim marriages intact!

A Muslim friend of mine was explaining to me that basically white girls are seen as just something to f**k, like prostitutes. Mainly married men & fathers can carry on being good dad’s & fathers & just rape white girls like a release. “They don’t see it as rape, like they don’t see shagging a goat as rape.”

She said “like some white blokes watch porn, they go & ‘shag’ a white girl”. She’s said it so flippantly. To them, “rape” would be to force yourself on a “pure” Muslim woman. To them, this isn’t “rape” — these girls are nothing. Just shit on their shoes. They barely see them as human.

“She said the wives know & don’t even care, because most of them don’t love their husbands anyway, a lot of the marriages are arranged, so as long as they don’t have to have sex with them, they couldn’t care less if they’re raping white girls — if it ‘keeps them (their husbands) off their backs’”. “She was trying to say it to me like a positive thing. “This is why most Muslim marriages last so long” she said, “because they don’t have to worry about the sex side of things — he can just get laid when he wants, & she can get on with being a wife.. you know like in white British marriages & they all break up because the wife won’t shag her husband, & so he has an affair?

“‘Well, like, in Muslim communities, the wives, unless they need or want a baby, if they don’t want sex, they just let him or encourage him to got off and f**k a white girl’. “She was saying this to me like it was all perfectly normal & didn’t know why I was so shocked or angry about it.”

Europe 2070, via End Wokeness:

 

Antwerp: ‘demographic Islamic colonization is almost complete’. By Remix.

In the 2025–2026 school year, 56.1 percent of the 22,273 pupils in Antwerp’s municipal primary and secondary schools are Muslim, according to figures supplied by Antwerp’s education agency. …

Vlaams Belang parliamentarian Filip Dewinter…: “In our Antwerp schools, the ‘kafirs’ — the unbelieving Flemings, that is — are already a modest minority. Demographic Islamic colonization is not only well underway… It is almost complete.” …

Nearly half of primary students in Antwerp speak a language other than Dutch at home in recent data, and debates over religious holidays, dress codes, and integration are now commonplace…..

In Vienna … now close to 50 percent of elementary schoolchildren. In some schools, 90 percent of the students are Muslim.

The left is allying with the wrong people:

 

Assimilation? Fuhgeddaboudit! By politician Joe Martin in the UK:

We were told those arriving would assimilate, THAT IS A LIE, we can’t even see their faces. I’ve even seen CHILDREN wearing them.

 

 

Still our ruling class turns a blind eye. How dumb can they be? Or are some of them evil?

One Nation’s Policy on Immigration

One Nation’s Policy on Immigration. By Ryan Dally.

While Labor keeps locking Australians into hundreds of billions in migration costs, Pauline Hanson has announced a hard reset:

• Humanitarian intake slashed by 90%, from 20,000 down to 2,000 places.

• Permanent parent visas abolished.

• Net negative migration for three years, then a hard ceiling of 100,000.

• Ordinary new migration banned from DFAT “Do Not Travel” countries, Afghanistan, Syria, Somalia, Yemen and others. …

The costs of the present system:

Each humanitarian entrant: $523,000 lifetime cost.

Each permanent parent migrant: $515,000.

Our people aren’t entering a birth rate arms race with you Bushra. By Restore Australia:

None of you should be in the West and birth rates are suppressed mainly due to mass immigration.

Westerners cannot live like third worlders, we do not like to live ten to a house or to marry our cousins and to live in huge extended families and communities. We need space and prosperity. You are all collectively ruining that.

Mass Immigration Lies, by Restore Australia:

  • They aren’t skilled …
  • There is no such thing as a skills shortage
  • There is no home building crisis
  • Migrants don’t solve the ageing population (they also age too, as wild as that may seem)
  • Migrants are net economic detractors
  • Migrants did not build our nations
  • The health service would benefit from their removal
  • House prices are astronomical due to their importation
  • Now we are competing with them for birth rates in our own homelands.

 

Everything is breaking — the second world scam?

Everything is breaking — the second world scam?

Major outages in November:

  • Microsoft 365 (Nov 12-14, software bug), F
  • AA ground stop (Nov 13, router/aging systems, ~10k flights),
  • Chase/banks + United (Nov 16, tech bugs),
  • Optimizely supply-chain cyber (Nov 16, 178 sites incl Zoom/CNN/HSBC),
  • NSA Net (today, no cyber evidence),
  • Apple services (today, iCloud/Pay/App Store).

Krzysztof Szczawinski:

COVID was the first global scam. AI scaremongering will most likely be the second. …

The [covid] formula was simple: take a real phenomenon, exaggerate its scale, dominate the information environment, then sell extraordinary measures as the only responsible choice. The virus was dangerous enough to frighten people and nowhere near dangerous enough to justify the response.

If it worked once, someone will try again. But not with another virus – too many people have learned the game. And the ideal racket needs panic without destruction. You cannot milk a dead cow. Governments do not need dead subjects. They need productive ones. That is also why war is becoming a clumsy tool: why destroy wealth you can redistribute?

Climate is too slow — a catastrophe permanently scheduled for the future works as a framework, not as a racket.

AI is the perfect candidate. It is real, powerful, fast, and almost impossible for ordinary people to verify. And it concerns information itself — the clearest lesson of COVID was that whoever controls information controls interpretation.

The script almost writes itself.

  • First come years of warnings from scientists, CEOs and former insiders.
  • Then a series of incidents: a self-driving car kills, a chatbot blackmails, an algorithm crashes a market. Some are real, some exaggerated, some staged, and for the narrative the difference hardly matters.
  • Then dramatic resignations. These are already happening.
  • Then the big event: networks down, banks frozen, grids flickering. Nobody knows whether it was AI, sabotage or a bug – so whoever controls the narrative decides.
  • Then comes the solution: certified operating systems, digital ID, licensed hardware, bans on open-source models, limits on encryption, and remote kill switches in every processor. Every measure is a new market, and every market a new fortune. Fear first, control second, profit third.

AI does not need to be invented. Only the catastrophe does. The accident becomes an emergency, the emergency becomes a measure, and the measure becomes permanent — the only part of any emergency that never ends.

World wars were numbered. Why not world scams?

Is this part of what Western governments have been warning about? Phillip Nieto in The Daily Mail:

JD Vance has told Americans they do not need a bunker or a food stockpile …

Ingraham had asked him point blank whether Americans should be prepping for a major global catastrophe. It comes after Britain and France have told their own citizens to keep days of food and water at home.

Vance brushed off the reporting behind the question, including accounts of Pentagon bases preparing to run off the grid for 90 days, as ‘just basic good government, making sure that our military is prepared, God forbid, if there was a crisis.’

Hackers?? Maybe, says Google.

Meanwhile, Google has warned corporate America that hackers powered by artificial intelligence are running autonomous attacks across major systems.

The company’s report released on Monday claims these AI hackers can constantly work around security patches, write working exploits and fire them at online servers.

Google drew no connection between its findings and last week’s failures, and federal officials say they have found no evidence that anyone attacked anything.

The French reckon their mass refrigerator failures were due to Iranian hackers.

Nvidia’s Jensen Huang was building an open AI ecosystem that threatened Anthropic’s business model

Nvidia’s Jensen Huang was building an open AI ecosystem that threatened Anthropic’s business model. By Alistair Barr at Business Insider.

Jensen Huang’s dramatic departure from Nvidia may be the best thing to happen to Anthropic just as the AI startup prepares to go public this week.

Under Huang, Nvidia was investing heavily in cheaper, more open AI models that compete with Anthropic’s offerings. The chip giant was also backing startups developing these alternative models and helping make them widely available.

That threatened Anthropic’s business model, which involves spending heavily to develop closed AI models and charges customers to use them, often at higher prices than open alternatives.

“People really need to understand that the ‘Cold War’ going on here is that Nvidia was on a titanic collision course with the labs,” the CEO of a leading AI startup told Business Insider. .. [He] described an ambitious Nvidia strategy to develop its own AI models, invest in rival startups, and build an ecosystem that could challenge not just Anthropic, but OpenAI too.

Anthropic benefits:

This strategy was just beginning to come together. But with Huang gone, the threat has diminished considerably.

The timing is extraordinary. Anthropic is preparing for a stock market debut this week that could value it at $1.4 trillion.

Investors are being asked to make an enormous bet on the future profitability of its AI services. Huang was helping build a world in which companies wouldn’t necessarily have to pay Anthropic for that intelligence. …

China hawks also benefit:

Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has advocated for very strict limits on advanced US chip sales to China, arguing these restrictions are essential to maintaining America’s technological lead.

Huang fought against those restrictions, warning that shutting China out would encourage Chinese companies to develop competing technology.

Now he’s gone, Anthropic’s worldview is prevailing. On Monday, the US government rolled out new restrictions that close a loophole that allowed Chinese firms to use Nvidia GPUs by renting them from data centers outside China.

Starts to make more sense. It would certainly explain the timing of the release of information on Huang’s affairs.

Stephen Molyneux:

NVIDIA is going to get torn apart by the state and the media because its leader supported Trump and wanted open-source AI.

Islamic Invention Fraud

Islamic Invention Fraud. By Cremieux Recueil.

Growing up, it was a common trope that cultures that we now associate with poverty, violence, and oppression were once world-leading…

Have you ever heard the name “Jagged_85”? If you’re a history buff, you’ve probably at least heard of some of his claims. For example:

  • Muslims invented funnels and sieves. …
  • Ibn Sahl first described the parabolic mirror.
  • An Islamic water clock from the 12th century had the earliest copper pipes. …
  • The Brethren of Purity proposed a heliocentric universe in the 10th century.
  • Darwin drew on Ibn Miskawayh’s work to develop the theory of evolution.
  • Al-Ghazali directly influenced Descartes’ later philosophical work.
  • Taqi al-Din invented the telescope sometime in the 1570s. …
  • Muhammad ibn Musa discovered gravity between planets
  • Al-Biruni discovered elliptical planetary orbits.
  • Al-Jazari invented flow regulators and feedback control …
  • Al-Battani discovered relativity a millennium before Einstein.

Jagged_85 vandalized thousands of articles while making over 87,000 Wikipedia edits in the time between starting in 2005 and being caught in 2012.

Those edits have led to hundreds of false claims misattributed to history books and papers, and now, those claims are alive on the internet, being repeated carelessly and promoted as if they’re true, when they are anything but….

The way a Jagged_85 claim works is straightforward. He rarely ever fully fabricated claims and they always had some sort of source document attached to them, from which you could usually sort-of see what he was getting at.

As an example, take the claim that Muslims invented funnels and sieves between 721 and 925. Jagged_85 did cite a source, it just didn’t say what it was cited for. What it actually provided readers was a list of laboratory equipment used by Muslim scholars, among which one could find funnels and sieves. The crucial issue, however, is that it never said they invented them, and in fact, it showed that they had been in use since Antiquity by Roman and Greek scholars. That last bit went unmentioned in places where the work was cited. …

It makes them feel so virtuous. You know what will happen if you deny their feelings.

[Some] people want to believe them; it is fashionable to talk about an exaggerated Muslim Golden Age and era of invention…

 

 

So woke:

What the Jagged_85 saga shows us is that with a little gumption, anyone can flood our shared information environment with garbage. They can have lies and exaggerations cited by thousands of scholars, educational programs and pamphlets, museum exhibits, journalists, and search engines alike, because no one checks, and people get lazy.

Who knows how many Jagged_85 edits have survived in the public consciousness, making people feel wrongly ‘informed’ about Islam and the Muslim world? Knowing just a few dozen of them, I can personally attest that I see them multiple times a year.

Anthony Albanese is concerned about disinformation and will do something about this — in a way that harms white Christian men.