Islamic Invention Fraud

Islamic Invention Fraud. By Cremieux Recueil.

Growing up, it was a common trope that cultures that we now associate with poverty, violence, and oppression were once world-leading…

Have you ever heard the name “Jagged_85”? If you’re a history buff, you’ve probably at least heard of some of his claims. For example:

  • Muslims invented funnels and sieves. …
  • Ibn Sahl first described the parabolic mirror.
  • An Islamic water clock from the 12th century had the earliest copper pipes. …
  • The Brethren of Purity proposed a heliocentric universe in the 10th century.
  • Darwin drew on Ibn Miskawayh’s work to develop the theory of evolution.
  • Al-Ghazali directly influenced Descartes’ later philosophical work.
  • Taqi al-Din invented the telescope sometime in the 1570s. …
  • Muhammad ibn Musa discovered gravity between planets
  • Al-Biruni discovered elliptical planetary orbits.
  • Al-Jazari invented flow regulators and feedback control …
  • Al-Battani discovered relativity a millennium before Einstein.

Jagged_85 vandalized thousands of articles while making over 87,000 Wikipedia edits in the time between starting in 2005 and being caught in 2012.

Those edits have led to hundreds of false claims misattributed to history books and papers, and now, those claims are alive on the internet, being repeated carelessly and promoted as if they’re true, when they are anything but….

The way a Jagged_85 claim works is straightforward. He rarely ever fully fabricated claims and they always had some sort of source document attached to them, from which you could usually sort-of see what he was getting at.

As an example, take the claim that Muslims invented funnels and sieves between 721 and 925. Jagged_85 did cite a source, it just didn’t say what it was cited for. What it actually provided readers was a list of laboratory equipment used by Muslim scholars, among which one could find funnels and sieves. The crucial issue, however, is that it never said they invented them, and in fact, it showed that they had been in use since Antiquity by Roman and Greek scholars. That last bit went unmentioned in places where the work was cited. …

It makes them feel so virtuous. You know what will happen if you deny their feelings.

[Some] people want to believe them; it is fashionable to talk about an exaggerated Muslim Golden Age and era of invention…

 

 

So woke:

What the Jagged_85 saga shows us is that with a little gumption, anyone can flood our shared information environment with garbage. They can have lies and exaggerations cited by thousands of scholars, educational programs and pamphlets, museum exhibits, journalists, and search engines alike, because no one checks, and people get lazy.

Who knows how many Jagged_85 edits have survived in the public consciousness, making people feel wrongly ‘informed’ about Islam and the Muslim world? Knowing just a few dozen of them, I can personally attest that I see them multiple times a year.

Anthony Albanese is concerned about disinformation and will do something about this — in a way that harms white Christian men.